Enter your keyword

Competing Against Civility

Competing Against Civility

I work in the world of athletics. I’ve always maintained that athletics is an amazing venue in which to learn life lessons. I’ve also always felt that athletics tends to bring out the best in the athletes and the worst in the fans. I’m guilty as charged. I become someone I don’t recognize when my favorite football team gets what I regard to be a bad call from an obviously biased ref. It takes all the self-control I can muster to calm down and not go off on the refs.

Did sports ever have a universally agreeable playbook on expected fan behavior? It seems to be the norm that for some reason we have deemed it acceptable to not just state our opinion, but to bully and torment without remorse or repercussion. In my latest book obsession “The Geography of Genius,” author Eric Weiner argues that what you honor as a culture grows.

It’s frightening how the arena of sports allows and encourages a Roman Colosseum-type of environment. How can we expect ourselves to go to the ugliest part of ourselves and switch it off once we get outside the arena? Or do we not expect that? Maybe we’re bringing our frustrations from the outside world into the arena and feel it’s an acceptable space to express our discontentment—as if getting heckled has its own page in the playbook that refs and athletes should understand.

How did we get here? Somewhere along the way we have mistaken civility with weakness. Is it not possible to be a rabid fan while maintaining civility and respect for the opponent? It always cracks me up when fans yell, “You SUCK!” or worse… to the opposing team. The only reason they’re so fired up is because they, in fact, don’t suck. The only times such vile ugliness comes out in fans is when the opposing team is a threat. We fans literally lose our minds. And when I say literally, I mean it. Recent neuroscience shows that when we get into this frame of mind the critical thinking parts of our brain stop lighting up. We actually lose the capacity to process new information.

There is a lot of finger pointing going on in the world these days. Many athletic events are now a microcosm of what’s going on in our country and the world. We have allowed our emotions to strangle the better parts of our humanity by turning us into reactionary animals. It is absolutely frightening. There is no longer an expected ethos of civility, decorum, common decency or God forbid accepted diversity.

How amazing would athletics be if we could enter the arena with the mindset of opportunity instead of adversity. As spectators, we can view the opposition with appreciation and respect. Respect they have earned through preparation and a willingness to compete. As competitors, when we appreciate our opponents for the challenges they present we can more easily cut to the truth of our strengths and weaknesses because, as I believe, iron sharpens iron. Let us view sport as a place to demonstrate the best of humanity; to challenge strategy, talent and philosophy, but not civility.

Related Posts

30 Comments
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mara
Mara
7 years ago

Miss Val, first and foremost I have to tell you how much I enjoy watching any UCLA meet … and college gymnastics in general. It is concept that I’ve heard of only a few years ago since here in Romania we only have club gymnastics. What I hate about competitions are the fans that tend to be so narrow minded sometimes. I’ve heard people calling a gymnast a coward because she would not compete with a fractured leg. So imagine my surprise when I came across this whole universe on college athletics with its fun gymnastics, loud fans and athletes… Read more »

Penny
Penny
7 years ago

Hello Miss Val, I’m just a little old lady born and raised in Los Angeles, CA, and living in Utah (18 years). I thought I would splurge and buy season tickets to see the U of U gymnast at the Huntsman Center. I was excited when I heard the Bruins were coming to town. UCLA has so much talent, and your gymnast genuinely seem to enjoy themselves. I agree with what you have said about civility, and I was shocked and appalled at how your talented gymnast were treated by many of the fans. Instead of enjoying each gymnast for… Read more »

Emilia
Emilia
7 years ago

Miss Val, thank you for writing this, I wholeheartedly agree. I’m a huge sports fan and I’ve played soccer and lacrosse since I was a little kid and have experience this myself. A few years ago I increasingly received rude, mean comments when I was successful and people cheered and laughed when I wasn’t. I was semi-pro but still just a kid and they were mostly adults. I still enjoyed the sport and as much as I tried to ignore them, the harassing sucked all the fun out of competing. Now as a college student I’ve let go of that… Read more »

John
John
7 years ago

I cannot recall exactly when I attended my first UCLA gymnastics meet (I graduated in 1983, but I was a commuter and had to work weekends for the most part so I couldn’t attend many events on campus), but it was the year the football players made their presence felt. This was actually appropriate as I brought a football mentality to the sport, like I did for all sports: the opponent was evil and if my team lost the referees certainly had a hand in the defeat! So, imagine my surprise when there were no cheers when an opposition performer… Read more »